[Dragaera] Drive-by poll about titles
Scott Schultz
scott at cjhunter.com
Thu Jun 28 12:56:05 PDT 2007
>I'm curious why _Taltos_ is coming up so often. I don't think the
>intercutting threads or the deus ex witchcraft ending work all that well.
Matter of taste, I suppose. The intercutting threads worked quite
effectively for me. The "deus ex witchcraft" as you refer to it actually
struck me as a clever conclusion to the dilemma of the protagonists, and the
spell casting thread running through the chapter headers was interesting in
its own right and served to build up suspense once its relationship to the
main storyline became clear.
Granted, it might be challenging to present it properly in an audio book.
Out of curiosity, I've compiled a count of the voting so far. As of 6/28
12:40pm PDT the standings are as follows:
The Phoenix Guards 20
Taltos 18
Jhereg 15
Issola 13
To Reign In Hell 09
Agyar 05
Dragon 05
The Sun, Moon, Stars 04
Yendi 04
Cowboy Feng's Space Bar 03
Brokedown Palace 03
Phoenix 02
Orca 02
Viscount of Adrilankha 02
Five Hundred Years After02
There's a bit of fudging due to a couple of respondents being less than
precise about their choices, but it has hardly any effect on the overall
outcome. TPG and Taltos are the clear winners (while tallying the votes, it
felt distinctly like a neck and neck horse race) with Jhereg, Issola, and To
Reign in Hell rounding out the winner's circle.
More information about the Dragaera
mailing list