[Dragaera] Sethra and Paarfi

[Steve Rapaport]

Tomas,

The theory linked does NOT pretend Paarfi might be Sethra -- "mouthpiece" is
not the same as "secret identity"!  Rather it speculates that Paarfi has far
too much information not to have had extensive interviews with Sethra at
some point.

So the question goes that if Paarfi didn't have extensive interviews with
Sethra, how did he find out so much?  And if he did, how could he have
written other than what Sethra desired?

Steve the Younger

2008/4/28 Tom Foolery <tomasfoolery at gmail.com>:

> Philip Hart wrote:
>
>
>
> > See http://dragaera.wikia.com/wiki/Speculation:Paarfi_of_Roundwood
> >
> > Basically one asks how Paarfi knows what he knows, if he knows it,
> > and how he got it published.  Then one asks Cui bono?
> >
>
> Thanks!
>
> What is interesting about this is that many of the so-called "proofs" can
> be
> actually used to disprove the theory as well, for example, this line:
>
> "Or perhaps the conclusion of the conflict with the Jenoine will turn out
> to
> have involved collateral damage - such as heavy civilian casualties - or
> unpopular restrictions of civic liberties). " Retrieved from "
> http://dragaera.wikia.com/wiki/Speculation:Paarfi_of_Roundwood"
>
> Which would mean that there would be no need for any justification.
>  Paarfi
> would be writing propaganda due to the nature of the world he lives in.
>  He
> mocks Morrolan possibly because Morrolan deserves it from actions unknown
> at
> this time... or possibly Mr. Brust is using a mouthpiece to tease the
> friend
> who created Morrolan.  But Sethra as Paarfi?  I don't know... while I have
> trouble imagining something that Sethra can't do...
>
> from: http://dragaera.wikia.com/wiki/Paarfi_of_Roundwood:
> "It is a bit difficult to describe *Paarfi of Roundwood*, and far be it
> from
> the writers of these articles to attempt a full portrait of such a
> complicated figure. For who among us could attempt to enlighten the
> visitors
> to this location with a full conjuration of such a man, a
> Hawk<http://dragaera.wikia.com/wiki/Hawk>,
> an author, and an historian; a lover, a fraud, a man respected by all,
> except for those who detest him; an inventor of tall tales; victim of
> unfounded literary court cases and also the occasional paternity court
> case.
> "
>
> Color me unconvinced on that aspect.
>
> Of course, that could have been written with tongue firmly in cheek, since
> there are no references to actual printed information - but Sethra
> fathering
> children?  While Drien supposedly did something along those lines... I
> don't
> know.  Seems to be a bit of speculation in a non speculative section of
> the
> wiki, right?  Unless that has been accepted as true?
>
> About the rest of it, how does Paarfi know what he knows?  The same
> way everyone else does, they try mightily to bribe those who would know,
> and
> fill in the blanks with mighty guesses, right?  Or maybe Paarfi has access
> to all of Vlad's stories?
>
> I'd be more interested in saying Paarfi is Pel (or even Tukko), but Mr.
> Brust did say that no one we've met is anyone else we've met (will cite as
> needed, I suppose.  Sure he was talking about Mario, but it's awfully
> precise...).  Perhaps I am generalizing and painting with a broad brush -
> but I would say Paarfi is Paarfi, the Empire's version of Andrew Martin (a
> scandal biographer, to save you the google effort).  Perhaps Paarfi has
> Kragar disease and can hear things he probably shouldn't?
>
> Anyway, as always, there are more questions than answers, just like life.
>  I
> won't disagree with the theory, since anything not directly said by Mr.
> Brust himself is subjective anyway, but I don't subscribe to it, yet.
>
> Respectfully,
>
> Tomas
> _______________________________________________
> Dragaera mailing list
> Dragaera at lists.dragaera.info
> http://lists.dragaera.info/listinfo.cgi/dragaera-dragaera.info
>



-- 
\Steve